Skip to content

Ultimate Movie Rankings

Ranking Movies Since 2011

Menu
  • Robert Duvall Movies
  • 2026 Movies – GOAT Debuts In 3rd Place
  • About
  • Site Index
  • Newest UMR Pages
  • Yearly Reviews 1925-2025
  • 2026 In Memoriam
  • 2025 Movies – Includes All Oscar Nominations
  • Forums
  • UMR Movie Thoughts
Menu

Susan Hayward Movies

Want to know the best Susan Hayward movies?  How about the worst Susan Hayward movies?  Curious about Susan Hayward’s box office grosses or which Susan Hayward movie picked up the most Oscar® nominations? Need to know which Susan Hayward movie got the best reviews from critics and audiences and which got the worst reviews? Well you have come to the right place….because we have all of that information.

I have been a bad son.  My mother, probably the biggest UltimateMovieRankings.com fan out there, has been asking for a Susan Hayward movie page for a very long time.  At one point I thought I would do a Susan Hayward page as a Mother’s Day gift to my mom.  Well that did not work…but finally after seeing another 6 months pass….I have finally written a UltimateMovieRankings page on 5 time Oscar® nominated and 1958’s Best Actress Oscar® winner….Susan Hayward. 

Her IMDb page shows 64 acting credits from 1937-1972. This page will rank Susan Hayward movies from Best to Worst in six different sortable columns of information. Television shows, shorts, cameos and movies that were not released in theaters were not included in the rankings.

Susan Hayward in her biggest box office hit of her career....1967's The Valley of the Dolls
Susan Hayward in her biggest box office hit of her career….1967’s The Valley of the Dolls

Susan Hayward Movies Ranked In Chronological Order With Ultimate Movie Rankings Score (1 to 5 UMR Tickets) *Best combo of box office, reviews and awards.

Year Movie (Year) Rating S
Year Movie (Year) Rating S
1939 Beau Geste (1939)
1958 I Want to Live! (1958)
AA Best Actress Win
1955 I'll Cry Tomorrow (1955)
AA Best Actress Nom
1944 The Fighting Seabees (1944)
1952 With a Song in My Heart (1952)
AA Best Actress Nom
1955 Soldier of Fortune (1955)
1948 Tap Roots (1948)
1946 Canyon Passage (1946)
1954 Garden of Evil (1954)
1954 Demetrius and the Gladiators (1954)
1952 The Snows of Kilimanjaro (1952)
1949 House of Strangers (1949)
1942 The Forest Rangers (1942)
1944 And Now Tomorrow (1944)
1942 I Married a Witch (1942)
1944 The Hairy Ape (1944)
1942 Reap the Wild Wind (1942)
1951 David and Bathsheba (1951)
1961 Back Street (1961)
1953 White Witch Doctor (1953)
1967 Valley of the Dolls (1967)
1952 The Lusty Men (1952)
1951 Rawhide (1951)
1947 They Won't Believe Me (1947)
1949 My Foolish Heart (1949)
AA Best Actress Nom
1951 I'll Climb The Highest Mountain (1951)
1947 Smash-Up: The Story of a Woman (1947)
AA Best Actress Nom
1955 Untamed (1955)
1953 The President's Lady (1953)
1956 The Conqueror (1956)
1946 Deadline At Dawn (1946)
1949 Tulsa (1949)
1943 Hit Parade of 1943 (1943)
1951 I Can Get It For You Wholesale (1951)
1941 Adam Had Four Sons (1941)
1948 The Saxon Charm (1948)
1959 Thunder in the Sun (1959)
1947 The Lost Moment (1947)
1961 Ada (1961)
1961 The Marriage-Go-Round (1961)
1964 Where Love Has Gone (1964)
1938 Girls On Probation (1938)
1967 The Honey Pot (1967)
1941 Among The Living (1941)
1959 Woman Obsessed (1959)
1939 Our Leading Citizen (1939)
1941 Sis Hoskins (1941)
1943 Jack London (1943)
1943 Young and Willing (1943)
1972 The Revengers (1972)
1939 $1000 a Touchdown (1939)
1957 Top Secret Affair (1957)
1963 Stolen Hours (1963)
1962 I Thank a Fool (1962)

Susan Hayward Movies Can Be Ranked 6 Ways In This Table

The really cool thing about this table is that it is “user-sortable”. Rank the movies anyway you want.

  • If Susan Hayward movie title has a blue link…then that means we have a You Tube on that movie
  • Sort Susan Hayward movies by co-stars of the movie
  • Sort Susan Hayward movies by adjusted domestic box office grosses using current movie ticket cost.
  • Sort Susan Hayward movies by box office rank by year of release
  • Sort Susan Hayward movies how they were received by critics and audiences.  60% rating or higher should indicate a good movie.
  • Sort by how many Oscar® nominations and how many Oscar® wins each Susan Hayward movie received. Ultimate Movie Rankings (UMR) Score.  UMR Score puts box office, reviews and awards into a mathematical equation and gives each movie a score.
R Movie (Year) UMR Co-Star Links Adj. B.O. Worldwide (mil) Review Oscar Nom / Win UMR Score
R Movie (Year) UMR Co-Star Links Actual B.O. Domestic (mil) Adj. B.O. Domestic (mil) Adj. B.O. Worldwide (mil) B.O. Rank by Year Review Oscar Nom / Win UMR Score S
1 Beau Geste (1939) Gary Cooper 5.80 258.9 258.90 22 86 02 / 00 98.4
3 I Want to Live! (1958)
AA Best Actress Win
Simon Oakland 9.10 190.5 190.50 18 83 06 / 01 98.3
2 I'll Cry Tomorrow (1955)
AA Best Actress Nom
Richard Conte 17.20 412.4 412.40 10 77 04 / 01 97.5
3 The Fighting Seabees (1944) John Wayne 5.90 230.5 230.50 55 78 01 / 00 96.8
5 With a Song in My Heart (1952)
AA Best Actress Nom
Thelma Ritter 9.20 208.3 208.30 14 71 05 / 01 96.2
7 Soldier of Fortune (1955) Clark Gable 7.90 188.9 263.00 36 76 00 / 00 95.2
6 Tap Roots (1948) Van Heflin &
Boris Karloff
6.60 205.6 265.60 35 71 00 / 00 94.8
8 Canyon Passage (1946) Dana Andrews 7.80 279.9 395.80 36 68 01 / 00 94.2
9 Garden of Evil (1954) Gary Cooper &
Richard Widmark
8.90 240.7 240.70 30 68 00 / 00 94.1
10 Demetrius and the Gladiators (1954) Victor Mature 12.10 330.0 330.00 18 66 00 / 00 93.3
11 The Snows of Kilimanjaro (1952) Gregory Peck &
Ava Gardner
18.10 410.4 410.40 3 64 02 / 00 93.2
12 House of Strangers (1949) Edward G. Robinson 5.60 161.5 161.50 46 77 00 / 00 93.0
14 The Forest Rangers (1942) Fred MacMurray 4.30 184.7 184.70 63 65 00 / 00 91.4
12 And Now Tomorrow (1944) Alan Ladd 6.50 252.0 252.00 40 60 00 / 00 91.1
17 I Married a Witch (1942) Fredric March 3.10 135.5 135.50 85 78 01 / 00 90.7
19 The Hairy Ape (1944) William Bendix 3.90 151.2 151.20 87 71 01 / 00 89.9
14 Reap the Wild Wind (1942) John Wayne 11.40 492.6 492.60 6 52 03 / 01 89.8
17 David and Bathsheba (1951) Gregory Peck 13.50 337.1 337.10 5 50 05 / 00 89.2
20 Back Street (1961) John Gavin 7.60 127.9 127.90 28 75 01 / 00 88.6
22 White Witch Doctor (1953) Robert Mitchum 7.60 157.8 157.80 31 62 00 / 00 87.2
19 Valley of the Dolls (1967) Patty Duke 50.00 516.5 516.50 6 48 01 / 00 87.0
21 The Lusty Men (1952) Robert Mitchum 4.20 94.7 94.70 77 82 00 / 00 87.0
24 Rawhide (1951) Tyrone Power 5.60 139.3 139.30 52 67 00 / 00 86.6
23 They Won't Believe Me (1947) Robert Young 3.60 120.5 184.40 95 72 00 / 00 86.3
26 My Foolish Heart (1949)
AA Best Actress Nom
Dana Andrews 5.10 147.4 216.00 57 61 02 / 00 85.9
27 I'll Climb The Highest Mountain (1951) Rory Calhoun 6.10 153.6 153.60 38 59 00 / 00 85.5
29 Smash-Up: The Story of a Woman (1947)
AA Best Actress Nom
Lee Bowman 4.70 160.2 227.50 72 54 02 / 00 85.0
31 Untamed (1955) Tyrone Power 7.10 171.7 171.70 40 48 00 / 00 83.3
28 The President's Lady (1953) Charlton Heston 4.10 85.2 85.20 88 74 02 / 00 83.2
27 The Conqueror (1956) John Wayne 12.90 292.2 292.20 16 37 00 / 00 82.0
30 Deadline At Dawn (1946) Bill Williams 3.00 108.6 108.60 102 65 00 / 00 81.5
32 Tulsa (1949) Robert Preston 4.40 129.2 129.20 69 56 01 / 00 81.0
35 Hit Parade of 1943 (1943) Gail Patrick 3.60 149.4 149.40 87 44 02 / 00 78.1
33 I Can Get It For You Wholesale (1951) Dan Dailey &
George Sanders
4.10 101.8 101.80 88 59 00 / 00 76.6
34 Adam Had Four Sons (1941) Ingrid Bergman 2.20 99.1 99.10 108 59 00 / 00 76.5
36 The Saxon Charm (1948) Robert Montgomery 2.40 74.0 74.00 128 64 00 / 00 73.5
39 Thunder in the Sun (1959) Jeff Chandler 4.70 98.2 98.20 54 54 00 / 00 71.7
37 The Lost Moment (1947) Robert Cummings 2.00 67.1 67.10 137 64 00 / 00 71.4
38 Ada (1961) Dean Martin 3.60 60.3 60.30 63 64 00 / 00 69.7
40 The Marriage-Go-Round (1961) James Mason 3.70 62.7 62.70 60 62 00 / 00 67.6
42 Where Love Has Gone (1964) Bette Davis 8.30 110.2 110.20 32 45 01 / 00 66.8
43 Girls On Probation (1938) Ronald Reagan 1.80 81.7 99.30 132 53 00 / 00 64.1
41 The Honey Pot (1967) Rex Harrison 2.50 25.8 25.80 85 67 00 / 00 58.6
44 Among The Living (1941) Frances Farmer 1.30 59.9 59.90 151 55 00 / 00 57.6
47 Woman Obsessed (1959) Stephen Boyd 3.20 67.0 67.00 74 52 00 / 00 56.3
45 Our Leading Citizen (1939) Bob Burns 1.00 43.9 43.90 178 59 00 / 00 54.9
46 Sis Hoskins (1941) Charles Butterworth 1.00 45.5 45.50 173 57 01 / 00 54.8
48 Jack London (1943) Michael O'Shea 2.10 88.8 88.80 113 43 01 / 00 53.4
49 Young and Willing (1943) William Holden 1.40 58.0 58.00 132 52 00 / 00 50.4
48 The Revengers (1972) William Holden &
Ernest Borgnine
4.50 33.4 33.40 68 59 00 / 00 48.8
50 $1000 a Touchdown (1939) Joe E. Brown 0.90 40.2 40.20 184 56 00 / 00 47.1
52 Top Secret Affair (1957) Kirk Douglas 1.40 31.9 31.90 135 55 00 / 00 41.1
53 Stolen Hours (1963) Michael Craig 2.60 37.4 37.40 78 48 00 / 00 29.4
54 I Thank a Fool (1962) Peter Finch 1.40 23.8 23.80 110 47 00 / 00 18.7

Stats and Possibly Interesting Things From The Above Susan Hayward Table

  1. Twenty-four Susan Hayward movies crossed the magical $100 million domestic gross mark.  That is a percentage of 44.44% of his movies listed. Valley of the Dolls (1967) was her biggest box hit.
  2. An average Susan Hayward movie grosses $106.50 million in adjusted box office gross.
  3. Using RottenTomatoes.com’s 60% fresh meter.  29 of Susan Hayward’s movies are rated as good movies…or 53.70% of his movies.  Beau Geste (1939) is her highest-rated movie while The Conqueror (1956) was her lowest-rated movie.
  4. Twenty-one Susan Hayward movies received at least one Oscar® nomination in any category…..or 38.88% of her movies.
  5. Four Susan Hayward movies won at least one Oscar® in any category…..or 7.40% of her movies.
  6. A “good movie” Ultimate Movie Rankings (UMR) Score is 60 or above.  38 Susan Hayward movies scored higher than the average….or 70.37% of her movies.  I’ll Cry Tomorrow (1955) got the highest UMR Score while I Thank A Fool (1962) got the lowest UMR Score.
Hayward 33333
Susan Hayward and John Wayne in 1956’s The Conqueror

Possibly Interesting Facts About Susan Hayward

1.  Susan Hayward (1917-1975) was born Edythe Marrener in Brooklyn, New York.

2.  When Susan Hayward was seven, she was hit by a car and suffered a fractured hip. Although doctors’ told her she might never walk again she was back on her feet in less than a year. The injury left her with one leg that was an inch and half shorter than the other, and she had to wear a lift in her shoe.  This cause her to have an ususual walk, but it became a trademark strut for her in Hollywood.

3.  Susan Hayward was one of 100s of actresses that arrived in Hollywood to try out for the Scarlett O’Hara part in Gone With The Wind.  Although she obviously did not get that part….she did start appearing in bit roles in movies from 1937-1938.  

4.  Susan Hayward’s first official screen role was in 1938’s Girls of Probation.  Her first real break was when she appeared in Gary Cooper’s hit film, Beau Geste (1939).  Once she got noticed…there was nothing stopping her as she became one of the biggest box office stars.

5.  Movie exhibitors voted Susan Hayward among the most popular stars in the country 8 times from 1951 to 1961. Her rankings during that time frame…1951-19th, 1952-9th, 1953-9th, 1954-14th, 1955-19th, 1956-13th,1959-10th and 1961-19th.

6.  Susan Hayward portrayed an alcoholic in three films.  She was nominated for an Oscar® for each of those performances. Those movies were 1947’s Smash-Up: The Story of a Woman, 1949’s My Foolish Heart , and 1955’s I’ll Cry Tomorrow.  She picked up two more Oscar® nominations in her career….1952’s With A Song In My Heart and 1958’s I Want To Live!.  She won the Best Actress Oscar® for I Want To Live!

7.  Susan Hayward was married two times in her life.  Her first marriage to B actor Jess Barker lasted from 1944 to 1954 and produced 2 children….fraternal twin sons named Gregory and Timothy. Her second marriage to Floyd Eaton Chalkley lasted from 1957 to 1966 (his death)…they had no children.

8.  Roles Susan Hayward turned down or was seriously considered for:  Elizabeth Taylor’s part in Cleopatra, Anne Bancroft’s part in The Graduate, Barbara Stanwyck’s part in Double Indemnity, Ingrid Bergman’s part in For Whom The Bell Tolls and parts in South Pacific, Can-Can and The Razor’s Edge.

9.  Susan Hayward is one of many members of the cast and crew of 1956’s Conqueror that eventually died of a type of cancer.  The Conqueror is sometimes called “An RKO Radioactive Picture.” It was filmed near a nuclear test site, and the set was contaminated by nuclear fallout.  After location shooting, contaminated soil was transported back to Hollywood in order to match interior shooting done there. Over the next 20 years, many actors (John Wayne) and crew members developed cancer.

10.  Susan Hayward’s footprints at Grauman’s Chinese Theatre are the only ones set in gold dust.

Check out Susan Hayward‘s career compared to current and classic actors.  Most 100 Million Dollar Movies of All-Time.   During our research we also discovered this excellent Susan website – Susan Hayward/Classic Film Star.

And finally check one of our few You Tube videos.  Ranking Susan Hayward’s Top Ten Movies.

Academy Award® and Oscar® are the registered trademarks of the Academy of Motion Arts and Sciences. Golden Globes® are the registered trademark and service mark of the Hollywood Foreign
If you do a comment….please ignore the email address and website section.
(Visited 1 times)

53 thoughts on “Susan Hayward Movies”

Comments navigation

Older comments
  1. Michael Anderson says:
    October 5, 2020 at 8:57 pm

    Just discovered this site, after watching Susan Hayward in “I Can Get It For You Wholesale” from 1951. Can’t understand why it is not on the list of her body of work. It was one of many great performances of strong, beautiful, head-strong women. Dan Dailey was also excellent in it.

    Reply
    1. Cogerson says:
      October 5, 2020 at 11:12 pm

      Hey Michael A. (1) Glad you discovered our website. (2) I Can Get It For You Wholesale is in our rankings…..coming in at #33 on the second stat table….and 1951 when looking at the first chronological order table. I have not seen it, but I will have to track that one down. Good feedback…hope you return to check out the 1000s of pages we have put together over the last 10 years.

      Reply
  2. Greg says:
    July 4, 2020 at 10:41 pm

    I have seen 20 Susan Hayward movies. The HIGHEST ranked movie I have seen is I’LL CRY TOMORROW. The LOWEST ranked movie I have seen is WHEN LOVE IS GONE. The highest ranked film I haven’t seen is BEAU GESTE. Favorites include I’LL CRY TOMORROW, MY FOOLISH HEART, SOLIDER OF FORTUNE, I’LL CLIMB THE HIGHEST MOUNTAIN, I WANT TO LIVE. SMASH UP-THE STORY OF A WOMAN. THE MARRIAGE GO ROUND, THE PRESIDENT’S LADY, I MARRIED A WITCH, and VALLEY OF THE DOLLS. Other Susan Hayward movies I have seen are RAWHIDE, UNTAMED, REAP THE WILD WIND, LUSTY MEN, THEY WON’T BELIEVE ME, DAVID AND BATHSHEBA, I CAN GET IT FOR YOU WHOLESALE, WHEN LOVE HAS GONE, THE SNOWS OF KILIMANJARO, and HOUSE OF STRANGERS. Just my opinion but Miss Hayward should have won her Oscar in 1955 for I’LL CRY TOMORROW as opposed to winning the award in 1958 for I WANT TO LIVE. She doesn’t give a bad performance in I WANT TO LIVE in my opinion but, by doing her own singing and dancing in I’LL CRY TOMORROW, she showed a whole new side to her talents that audiences didn’t often get to see.

    Reply
  3. Sidney Johnson says:
    February 17, 2020 at 1:03 pm

    Do you think Summer Flight 1963 should be “Stolen Hours”?

    Reply
    1. Cogerson says:
      February 18, 2020 at 7:03 am

      Hey Sidney. That movie goes by both titles. Not sure how I picked Summer Flight vs Stolen Hours…as I normally use the one IMDb uses. But…I redid the title….to include both. Put Stolen Hours first…since that is what IMDb has. Good catch. Your eagle eye efforts are greatly appreciated.

      Reply
  4. In The Shadows says:
    July 7, 2019 at 3:34 pm

    The Revengers was Hayward’s last theaterical movie and was released in June of 1972. Say Goodbye, Maggie Cole? was a television movie that aired in September 1972. IMDb credits Maggie Cole as her last movie but it never got released in theaters. So I feel you can answer the question both ways as long as you explain which way you are looking at the question. In my mind, The Revengers was Hayward’s last movie while Maggie Cole was her last acting role. Hope that helps.

    Reply
    1. Cogerson says:
      July 8, 2019 at 9:07 pm

      Good answer In The Shadows….hopefully Ken will read it. I am attaching your comment to his original “question comment”. Thanks again for providing this answer…you are the man.

      Reply

Comments navigation

Older comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Watch Naked Gun On Paramount Plus – Sign Up Today

Latest Comments

  • Mike HoF2020 on Jack Warden Movies
  • Mike HoF2020 on Site Index
  • Nick on Site Index
  • Mark Johnson on Ultimate Movie Rankings
  • Anonymous on Michael Peña Movies

Top Stars By Decades

  • Top Movie Stars of the 1930s
  • Top Movie Stars of the 1940s
  • Top Movie Stars of the 1950s
  • Top Movie Stars of the 1960s
  • Top Movie Stars of the 1970s
  • Top Movie Stars of the 1980s
  • Top Box Office Stars of the 1990s
  • Top Box Office Stars of the 2000s
  • Top Movie Stars of the 2010s

UMR’s Latest Movie Reviews

All-Time Most Popular UMR Pages 2011 – 2024

  • Pixar Movies vs DreamWorks Movies
  • Marvel Movies vs DC Movies
  • All Time Top Ticket Selling Movies
  • John Wayne Movies
  • Bette Davis Movies
  • Black Hawk Down Cast Then And Now
  • Bruce Willis Movies
  • Steve McQueen Movies
  • Elvis Presley Movies
  • Joan Crawford Movies
  • Disney Movies
  • Marilyn Monroe Movies
  • Cary Grant Movies
  • Abbott and Costello Movies
  • Alfred Hitchcock Movies
  • Clint Eastwood Movies
  • Spielberg vs Cameron
  • Kurt Russell Movies
  • Top Grossing Movies of 1939
  • 1946 Top Box Office Movies
  • Humphrey Bogart Movies
  • Michael Caine Movies
  • Burt Reynolds Movies
  • Doris Day Movies
  • Tom Hanks Movies
  • Gregory Peck Movies

Want to help our website survive? Consider buying one of our books.

©2026 Ultimate Movie Rankings | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme

Dynamic title for modals

Are you sure?

Please confirm deletion. There is no undo!